Ever heard about the 4 P's, AIDA, PAS and other copywriting formulas?
I've always been skeptical about those.
Not because I think they don't work.
But because I don't think they work every single time and for every single business.
There's no one size fits all in copywriting.
And picking the right formula to use requires at least some knowledge of your audience and market anyway. You already have to do the hard work, so why not do it for good and come up with your own information hierarchy?
At the same time, when I started out I copied a lot of great copywriters. No shame in saying that.
David Ogilvy had my side when he said: "until you've got a better answer, you copy."
And that's where the point is... in having the better answer.
I'm not against using formulas, but I'm against being lazy about writing good copy.
Formulas work well, when you know what you're talking about, but can even make you lose sales if you have no idea (of what your customers know or of where they're at when they land on your page for example).
Let's say you want to go with the classic AIDA formula: Attention, Interest, Desire, Action.
What are you going to use to get their attention? How are you pulling them in to create interest? What sparks their desire? And what's the best wayfor them to take action?
Unless you know all of these from researching your audience, there's no point in using that formula.
All of this is why any copywriter should steer clear of clients asking them about how many formulas they know and have used. Or why clients should avoid copywriters who talk incessantly about how many P's their copy contains.
Want to write copy that coverts?
Go get your better answer with your audience and then spruce it up with the right formula if you want.
(Or just get in touch)
Cheers,
Chris
I'm the founder and chief conversion copywriter at Conversion Alchemy. We help 7 and 8 figure SaaS and Ecommerce businesses convert more website visitors into happy customers. Unpacking Meaning is the only newsletter B2B SaaS leaders need to sharpen messaging and shorten sales cycles. A weekly email with one field-tested idea you can use to boost conversions without raising ad spend, make value obvious and friction low, and align teams with clear, scalable messaging.
Before you ask AI for better ad copy, read this I’m working with a client who wanted to launch his own ads using a writing kit we’d put together for him. The kit gives Claude the context it needs to write for his business: the messaging we’d developed, who the offer is for, the claims we can support, approved copy, and examples of my edits explaining what makes the writing work. It also includes prompts and a workflow for drafting and reviewing new copy. So instead of starting every chat with...
How do you hire a copywriter in 2026? How do you hire a copywriter in 2026? And with AI writing so much of our copy, do you even need one? I’d start by looking at what you need help with. If you understand your buyers, have clear positioning and messaging, and know how to judge the copy AI produces, you might not need a writer for every page or email. But if you’re still figuring out who you’re writing for and what you should say, getting AI to produce more drafts won’t answer those questions...
What your signup numbers aren’t telling you In preparing today’s webinar on early user discovery, I’ve been working with a fictional example: a product helping small agencies get work approved by their clients. Their problem? People sign up, but few get to the point where they’re actually receiving useful feedback. The founder wants to buy more traffic. It’s an understandable move. More people coming in gives you more chances to turn someone into a customer. But it also leaves an important...